HeaderImage 261113o

News & Events

Felicity Iredale and Luke McLean have been published in the Australian Health Law Bulletin

| Published by Felicity Iredale

RK Lawyer Felicity Iredale and Law Graduate Luke McLean have had an article published in the Australian Health Law Bulletin titled 'Applications for consent to special medical treatment — NXM (No 1) and NXM (No 2)'.

The New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal Guardianship Division (the Tribunal) handed down a decision regarding the standard required to be applied in determining an application for special medical treatment.

The Tribunal, in the decisions of NXM (No 1)¹ and NXM (No 2),² has reviewed the appropriate standard to be applied in consenting to special medical treatment resulting in infertility of a young woman with severe intellectual disability. The two decisions were independent of one another with the application in NXM (No 1) being brought by Miss NXM’s gynaecologist and the same application brought by her general practitioner in NXM (No 2). The Tribunal in NXM (No 2) held that the special medical treatment of a hysterectomy with ovarian conservation was necessary to prevent serious damage to a person’s health.

While this decision was made in New South Wales, it has wide-reaching relevance. Each state and territory in Australia has its own guardianship laws and legislation applying to special medical procedures. While a tribunal or court must follow those specific laws, the test and standard relating to procedures leading to infertility has been determined and settled by the High Court in Marion’s Case.

Therefore, the requirement that the procedure be a step of last resort will apply across the country. Courts or tribunals may also look to this decision or the other authorities cited in these cases for guidance as to the stringent nature of the test.

Read the full article here.

If you have any questions, please contact Michael Gorton AM on 03 9609 1505 or Felicity Iredale on 03 8602 7254. 

Our Contacts